Roth, V. (2011). Divergent. Katherine Tegen Books. ISBN: 9780062024022. 487 pages. $17.99,
Author Website: http://veronicarothbooks.blogspot.com/
Readers Annotation: Tris must choose what faction she wants to join; either the humble Abnegation faction of her family or the dangerous Dauntless faction.
Summary: All sixteen-year-olds must decide what faction they wish to join for the rest of their lives. Tris is a member of the Abnegation faction; a faction devoted to putting others first. During the test to see what factions are available, Tris receives three possible choices, rather than the normal two options. Tris is a Divergent; a person who can fit in a number of factions. She must keep this a secret as it could be dangerous in the wrong hands. Tris decides to leave her family and join the Dauntless faction. The Dauntless faction contains the warriors and the rebellious. After first no one thinks that Tris is going to make it as a Dauntless. But as time goes on, Tris proves herself over and over again, especially to a Dauntless known as Four.
Reading Level: Grades 8 and up
Interest Level: Grades 9 and up
Review and Evaluation: I was initially attracted to Divergent for two reasons. The first reason is the plot. It sounded similiar enough to The Hunger Games to be a decent readalike but not too similiar that it sounded like a direct copy. The second reason I was interested in Divergent is the setting. I’ve lived in a suburb of Chicago my entire life so the idea of a dystopian story taking place in a city I was familiar with sounded really great. I loved all of the details that Roth included in the setting. For example, the scene where they go to Navy Pier and climb the ferris wheel was so interesting. It makes you think what a future civilization would think of the times we call commonplace. To Tris and Four, there was no understandable use for a ferris wheel. Everyone in Tris’s world has a task. There was no leisure time equatable to our society.
Every dystopian society has to have some kind of authority system in place that causes the issues of the civilization. In societies like Divergent, the people truly believe that the political systems are helping the people, mainly because they do not see the negatives. It’s true that the people know about the Factionless, those without a faction who are basically homeless squatters, but they really don’t know them at all. I liked how Roth revealed slowly revealed the information that the political system was flawed. It wasn’t a complete shock, but the details were definitely relayed in a steady, piece-by-piece pace.
I thought that Roth’s choice of division was also very unique and interesting. In other books, people are divided by location, class standing, race, etc. Roth decides to divide the people by character traits. I can see the pros of this division. People with the same traits can learn from each other and become better members of society. However, I also can see the bad part. No one in this world is completely well-rounded. Everyone inhabits all of these traits initially, so the division just pigeon-holes everyone and stops them from developing. This is why Tris and Four are so important. They can relate to several factions and truly are the hope for the civilization.
Subjects/Genres: Bullying, Coming of Age, Death, Dystopian, Science Fiction, Thriller, Violence
Bibliotherapeutic Uses: Tris is struggling to fit in which is something that most teens deal with on a daily basis. Divergent is a story about someone overcoming huge odds and finding out who she is as a person.
Controversial Topics:
Violence – The Dauntless is a faction that thrives on domination. In order to be the best, you have to have little regrad for anyone but yourself.
- Defense – Roth includes this faction because it is a part of people represented in a concentrated manner. The Dauntless need to be violent to show the diversity of the other factions.
Booktalk Ideas:
Compare it to The Hunger Games
Discuss the different factions. Ask which ones the students would like to be a part of.
Could you leave your family forever to join a different faction?
Awards and Booklists:
- Goodreads Choice Award for Favorite Book, 2011
- Goodreads Choice Award for Best Young Adult Fantasy & Science Fiction, 2011
- ALA Teens’ Top Ten Nominee, 2012
- Children’s Choice Book Award Nominee Book of the Year, 2012
- Abraham Lincoln Award Nominee, 2014
- Georgia Peach Book Award for Teen Readers
- Rhode Island Teen Book Award
- School Libray Journal Best Books, 2012
Readalikes:
- The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins
- Matched by Ally Condie
- Delirium by Lauren Oliver
- Legend by Marie Lu
- Under the Never Sky by Veronica Rossi
Professional Reviews:
Kraus, D. (2011). Divergent (book review). Booklist, 107 (13), 56.
Staff reviewer (2011). Divergent (book review). Kirkus, 3 May 2011.
Staff reviewer (2011). Divergent (book review). Publishers Weekly, 258 (8).
Why I Chose This Book: As I stated earlier, I chose this book because I thought it would be a good readalike to The Hunger Games and I was excited about a dystopian set in Chicago.